Skip to content

Commit 2db23d7

Browse files
author
Delta Team
committed
PR_26175_OWNER_054: add Alfa consolidated batch closeout plan
1 parent f19fe45 commit 2db23d7

3 files changed

Lines changed: 228 additions & 121 deletions

File tree

‎docs_build/dev/reports/PR_26175_OWNER_054-alfa-consolidated-batch-closeout-plan.md‎

Lines changed: 112 additions & 0 deletions
Original file line numberDiff line numberDiff line change
@@ -0,0 +1,112 @@
1+
# PR_26175_OWNER_054 - Alfa Consolidated Batch Closeout Plan
2+
3+
## Executive Summary
4+
5+
PASS - Audit/report only. No PRs were merged, closed, or modified.
6+
7+
GitHub was used as authority for PR state. The old Alfa #96-#118 stack remains open as draft PRs, with every old PR based on another non-main Alfa stack branch. The consolidated replacement PRs #146, #148, #149, and #150 target `main`, but all refreshed as conflicting against current `main` after the latest governance/report merges.
8+
9+
Recommendation:
10+
11+
1. Merge consolidated PR #146 after resolving generated report conflicts and moving from draft to ready.
12+
2. Do not merge consolidated PR #148 as-is; treat it as needs-owner-decision because it carries older Game Hub parent/child behavior that may be superseded by #149.
13+
3. Merge consolidated PR #149 after resolving generated report conflicts and rechecking Game Hub behavior.
14+
4. Merge consolidated PR #150 after resolving generated report conflicts and rechecking Idea Board behavior.
15+
5. Close old PRs #96 through #118 as superseded after OWNER approves the consolidated merge/close batch.
16+
17+
## Consolidated PR Recommendations
18+
19+
| PR | Consolidated Scope | GitHub State | Mergeability Refresh | Recommendation | Blocker |
20+
| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
21+
| #146 `PR_26175_ALFA_015` | Foundation runtime consolidation for #96-#101 | Open draft | Conflicting | Merge after conflict resolution | Generated report conflicts in `codex_changed_files.txt` and `codex_review.diff`; draft state; Playwright browser blocked by missing Chromium in PR validation. |
22+
| #148 `PR_26175_ALFA_016` | Parent/child table consolidation for #103-#105 | Open draft | Conflicting | Needs OWNER decision; do not merge as-is | Generated report conflicts plus semantic risk: report describes Open Games parent-table identity and Game Summary child table, which may conflict with the later #149 two-child-row Game Hub direction. |
23+
| #149 `PR_26175_ALFA_017` | Game Hub interaction consolidation for #107-#113 | Open draft | Conflicting | Merge after conflict resolution | Generated report conflicts; draft state; Playwright browser blocked by missing Chromium in PR validation. |
24+
| #150 `PR_26175_ALFA_018` | Idea Board polish consolidation for #114-#116 | Open draft | Conflicting | Merge after conflict resolution | Generated report conflicts; draft state; Playwright browser blocked by missing Chromium in PR validation. |
25+
26+
## Recommended Merge Order
27+
28+
| Order | Action | Reason |
29+
| --- | --- | --- |
30+
| 1 | Resolve and merge #146 | Foundation/Game Journey persistence behavior is independent from the later Game Hub/Idea Board UI consolidation. |
31+
| 2 | OWNER decision on #148 | #148 should either be recreated from current main or closed if #149 is the accepted replacement for Game Hub parent/child behavior. |
32+
| 3 | Resolve and merge #149 | Carries the final current-main-safe Game Hub interaction direction and supersedes the old Batch C stack. |
33+
| 4 | Resolve and merge #150 | Carries the final Idea Board status polish and can follow #149 to preserve the consolidated Alfa sequence. |
34+
35+
## Old Alfa PR Close Map
36+
37+
| Old PR | Old Title | Stack Area | Close Recommendation |
38+
| --- | --- | --- | --- |
39+
| #96 | `PR_26174_ALFA_002-game-hub-project-intake-display` | Foundation A | Close as superseded by #146 and current main direction. |
40+
| #97 | `PR_26174_ALFA_003-game-hub-journey-bootstrap` | Foundation A | Close as superseded by #146 and current main direction. |
41+
| #98 | `PR_26174_ALFA_004-game-hub-progress-count-model` | Foundation A | Close as superseded by #146 and current main direction. |
42+
| #99 | `PR_26174_ALFA_005-idea-project-validation-polish` | Foundation A | Close as superseded by #146/#150 and current main direction. |
43+
| #100 | `PR_26174_ALFA_006-game-hub-empty-and-error-states` | Foundation A | Close as superseded by #146 and current main direction. |
44+
| #101 | `PR_26174_ALFA_007-game-journey-count-ui-polish` | Foundation A | Close as superseded by #146 and current main direction. |
45+
| #102 | `PR_26174_ALFA_008-alpha-stack-final-validation` | Validation wrapper | Close as superseded; validation-wrapper-only PR should not merge. |
46+
| #103 | `PR_26174_ALFA_009-game-hub-parent-child-table-layout` | Parent/child B | Close as superseded after OWNER decides #148 vs #149 final Game Hub shape. |
47+
| #104 | `PR_26174_ALFA_010-game-hub-source-idea-child-table-polish` | Parent/child B | Close as superseded after OWNER decides #148 vs #149 final Game Hub shape. |
48+
| #105 | `PR_26174_ALFA_011-game-hub-readiness-output-child-table` | Parent/child B | Close as superseded after OWNER decides #148 vs #149 final Game Hub shape. |
49+
| #106 | `PR_26174_ALFA_012-game-hub-parent-child-final-validation` | Validation wrapper | Close as superseded; validation-wrapper-only PR should not merge. |
50+
| #107 | `PR_26174_ALFA_013-game-hub-game-row-child-rows` | Interaction C | Close as superseded by #149. |
51+
| #108 | `PR_26174_ALFA_014-game-hub-parent-columns-center` | Interaction C | Close as superseded by #149/current main. |
52+
| #109 | `PR_26174_ALFA_015-game-hub-actions-and-setup-cleanup` | Interaction C | Close as superseded by #149/current main. |
53+
| #110 | `PR_26174_ALFA_016-game-hub-row-edit-add-selected-state` | Interaction C | Close as superseded by #149/current main. |
54+
| #111 | `PR_26174_ALFA_017-game-hub-guest-save-and-crew-cleanup` | Interaction C | Close as superseded by #149/current main. |
55+
| #112 | `PR_26174_ALFA_018-game-selection-button-state` | Interaction C | Close as superseded by #149/current main. |
56+
| #113 | `PR_26174_ALFA_019-game-hub-selected-button-and-crew-label` | Interaction C | Close as superseded by #149/current main. |
57+
| #114 | `PR_26174_ALFA_020-game-hub-idea-board-cleanup` | Idea Board D | Close as superseded by #150/current main. |
58+
| #115 | `PR_26174_ALFA_021-idea-board-status-filter-table-polish` | Idea Board D | Close as superseded by #150/current main. |
59+
| #116 | `PR_26174_ALFA_022-idea-board-status-dropdown-fix` | Idea Board D | Close as superseded by #150/current main. |
60+
| #117 | `PR_26174_ALFA_EOD-workstream-closeout` | EOD evidence | Close as superseded by consolidated closeout plan; archive as evidence only. |
61+
| #118 | `PR_26174_ALFA_EOD-final-closeout` | EOD evidence | Close as superseded by consolidated closeout plan; archive as evidence only. |
62+
63+
## Blockers
64+
65+
| Blocker | Applies To | Detail |
66+
| --- | --- | --- |
67+
| Draft state | #146, #148, #149, #150 | All consolidated PRs are still draft and should not merge until OWNER marks them ready or explicitly approves draft merge handling. |
68+
| Merge conflicts | #146, #148, #149, #150 | `gh pr view` refresh reported `CONFLICTING` for all four consolidated PRs. Non-destructive `git merge-tree` checks show generated report conflicts in `docs_build/dev/reports/codex_changed_files.txt` and `docs_build/dev/reports/codex_review.diff`. |
69+
| Semantic conflict | #148 | #148 includes older Game Hub parent-child behavior that may be superseded by #149. OWNER should decide close/recreate/merge before any #148 action. |
70+
| Browser validation unavailable | #146, #149, #150; likely #148 | Prior consolidated PR validation reports show Playwright blocked because local Chromium is missing. Do not install Chromium unless OWNER approves. |
71+
| Old PR stack bases | #96-#118 | Every old PR is based on another historical non-main stack branch, making direct merge inappropriate even when GitHub reports `MERGEABLE` within that stale stack. |
72+
73+
## GitHub Authority Notes
74+
75+
- `gh pr view` was used for PR #96 through #118 and #146 through #150.
76+
- Consolidated PR refresh command rechecked #146, #148, #149, and #150 after GitHub had time to update mergeability.
77+
- Non-destructive `git merge-tree` was used only to identify conflict surfaces; no merge, close, or branch delete was performed.
78+
79+
## Requirement Checklist
80+
81+
| Requirement | Status | Notes |
82+
| --- | --- | --- |
83+
| Start from `main` | PASS | `main` was checked before work. |
84+
| Hard stop if branch/worktree/sync invalid | PASS | Initial branch `main`, clean worktree, local/origin sync `0 0`; after `git pull --ff-only`, still `main`, clean, `0 0`. |
85+
| Read all Project Instructions | PASS | All files under `docs_build/dev/ProjectInstructions/` were read. |
86+
| Review consolidated Alfa PRs 015-018 | PASS | Reviewed #146, #148, #149, #150. |
87+
| Map against old Alfa PRs #96-#118 | PASS | Old PR close map included above. |
88+
| Recommend consolidated PR merge/hold/close action | PASS | Included above. |
89+
| Identify blockers | PASS | Included above. |
90+
| Do not merge PRs | PASS | No merge performed. |
91+
| Do not close PRs | PASS | No closure performed. |
92+
| Required reports and ZIP | PASS | `codex_review.diff`, `codex_changed_files.txt`, this report, and repo-structured ZIP are included. |
93+
94+
## Validation Lane
95+
96+
| Command | Status | Result |
97+
| --- | --- | --- |
98+
| `git pull --ff-only` | PASS | `main` fast-forwarded, then remained clean and synced. |
99+
| `gh pr view #96-#118,#146-#150 --json ...` | PASS | GitHub-authority PR inventory collected. |
100+
| `gh pr view #146,#148,#149,#150 --json mergeable` | PASS | Refreshed consolidated PR mergeability; all four reported `CONFLICTING`. |
101+
| `git merge-tree` non-destructive checks | PASS | Identified report conflicts without merging. |
102+
| Runtime code validation | N/A | Report-only PR; no runtime code changed. |
103+
104+
## Manual Validation Notes
105+
106+
- This plan intentionally does not resolve conflicts, mark PRs ready, close old PRs, merge consolidated PRs, or delete branches.
107+
- Old PRs #96-#118 should be closed only after OWNER explicitly approves the close batch.
108+
- Consolidated PR conflicts appear dominated by generated report files, but #148 requires a separate semantic decision because its Game Hub shape may no longer match the latest consolidated direction.
109+
110+
## Branch Validation
111+
112+
PASS - Work began from clean, synced `main`; implementation was made on `PR_26175_OWNER_054-alfa-consolidated-batch-closeout-plan`.

‎docs_build/dev/reports/codex_changed_files.txt‎

Lines changed: 3 additions & 9 deletions
Original file line numberDiff line numberDiff line change
@@ -1,9 +1,3 @@
1-
# git status --short
2-
3-
4-
# git diff --name-status main...HEAD
5-
A docs_build/dev/reports/PR_26175_OWNER_049-governance-report-merge-batch.md
6-
7-
# git diff --stat main...HEAD
8-
...6175_OWNER_049-governance-report-merge-batch.md | 128 +++++++++++++++++++++
9-
1 file changed, 128 insertions(+)
1+
docs_build/dev/reports/PR_26175_OWNER_054-alfa-consolidated-batch-closeout-plan.md
2+
docs_build/dev/reports/codex_changed_files.txt
3+
docs_build/dev/reports/codex_review.diff

0 commit comments

Comments
 (0)