Mod versions:
- DynamicTrees
1.7.2 (NeoForge 1.21.1) — latest release
- dtterralith
1.3.0
- dtarsnouveau
1.3.0
Summary
On load, SpeciesResourceLoader emits a WARN for deprecated species properties and silently discards the data with no migration — so affected species lose their per-climate and seasonal-fruiting behavior. All three mods ship the deprecated JSONs in their latest releases, so the problem is present out-of-the-box.
Warning (server log)
[main/WARN] [com.dtteam.dynamictrees.treepack.loader.SpeciesResourceLoader/]: The "environment_factors" property has been removed. Use "preferred_climate" instead! Species <id>.
[main/WARN] [com.dtteam.dynamictrees.treepack.loader.SpeciesResourceLoader/]: The "seasonal_fruiting_offset" property has been removed. Use "seasonal_offsets" instead! Species <id>.
On this server the count is 66 warnings (61 environment_factors + 5 seasonal_fruiting_offset) across:
dynamictrees:mega_spruce, dynamictrees:cherry- 59
dtterralith:* species (e.g. windswept_spruce, sakura, mega_ancient, lush_mahogany)
- 5
dtarsnouveau:* species (yellow/red/purple/green/blue_archwood)
Impact
The deprecated properties are read, logged, and dropped — no value is carried over to preferred_climate / seasonal_offsets. Affected species fall back to the default ClimateZoneType.TEMPERATE and default seasonal timing, which means incorrect growth rates, seed drops, and fruit production for anything outside temperate biomes (or for the 5 dtarsnouveau species whose intended seasonal fruiting no longer applies).
Expected behavior
Either:
- A migration: translate
environment_factors/seasonal_fruiting_offset to their replacements automatically (preferred), or
- Remove the deprecated keys from the shipped species JSONs (and emit the WARN only when a user's custom species uses them).
Currently the shipped default species trigger the warning and lose functionality on every load, which defeats the purpose of the fields in the first place.
Reproduction
Load a NeoForge 1.21.1 server with DynamicTrees 1.7.2 + dtterralith 1.3.0 + dtarsnouveau 1.3.0. Inspect the server log — the 66 WARNs appear during world load. No player action required.
Note
The accompanying addons (dtterralith, dtarsnouveau) are at their latest 1.21.1 releases, so they cannot be updated to fix this — the deprecated JSONs are what they currently ship.
Mod versions:
1.7.2(NeoForge 1.21.1) — latest release1.3.01.3.0Summary
On load,
SpeciesResourceLoaderemits a WARN for deprecated species properties and silently discards the data with no migration — so affected species lose their per-climate and seasonal-fruiting behavior. All three mods ship the deprecated JSONs in their latest releases, so the problem is present out-of-the-box.Warning (server log)
On this server the count is 66 warnings (61
environment_factors+ 5seasonal_fruiting_offset) across:dynamictrees:mega_spruce,dynamictrees:cherrydtterralith:*species (e.g.windswept_spruce,sakura,mega_ancient,lush_mahogany)dtarsnouveau:*species (yellow/red/purple/green/blue_archwood)Impact
The deprecated properties are read, logged, and dropped — no value is carried over to
preferred_climate/seasonal_offsets. Affected species fall back to the defaultClimateZoneType.TEMPERATEand default seasonal timing, which means incorrect growth rates, seed drops, and fruit production for anything outside temperate biomes (or for the 5 dtarsnouveau species whose intended seasonal fruiting no longer applies).Expected behavior
Either:
environment_factors/seasonal_fruiting_offsetto their replacements automatically (preferred), orCurrently the shipped default species trigger the warning and lose functionality on every load, which defeats the purpose of the fields in the first place.
Reproduction
Load a NeoForge 1.21.1 server with DynamicTrees 1.7.2 + dtterralith 1.3.0 + dtarsnouveau 1.3.0. Inspect the server log — the 66 WARNs appear during world load. No player action required.
Note
The accompanying addons (dtterralith, dtarsnouveau) are at their latest 1.21.1 releases, so they cannot be updated to fix this — the deprecated JSONs are what they currently ship.